xAI’s challenge against OpenAI’s dominance sparks debate over tech platform fairness
Elon Musk, the billionaire behind Tesla and xAI, has accused Apple of rigging its App Store rankings to favor OpenAI’s ChatGPT, threatening legal action to address what he calls a clear antitrust violation.
The dispute intensifies his rivalry with OpenAI and raises questions about competition in the AI industry
Elon Musk has ignited a firestorm by alleging that Apple is unfairly promoting OpenAI’s ChatGPT in its App Store, stifling competition from his AI venture, xAI, and its chatbot, Grok. His threat of “immediate legal action” underscores a broader battle over control and fairness in the rapidly evolving artificial intelligence landscape.
Musk’s Accusations
Claims of App Store Bias
On Monday, Musk took to his social media platform, X, to lambast Apple, claiming it is “impossible for any AI company besides OpenAI to reach No. 1 in the App Store.” He labeled this an “unequivocal antitrust violation” and vowed that xAI would pursue swift legal action.
Musk’s posts specifically criticized Apple for excluding both X and Grok from its “Must Have” app section, despite X being the top news app globally and Grok ranking fifth overall, according to AppFigures data.
Personal Rivalry Intensified
Musk’s accusations are steeped in his ongoing feud with OpenAI, which he co-founded in 2015 before parting ways in 2018 over strategic disagreements. His current lawsuit against OpenAI, seeking to block its shift to a for-profit model, reflects his contention that the organization betrayed its nonprofit mission.
Musk’s posts on X escalated the dispute, calling OpenAI CEO Sam Altman a “liar” and questioning whether Apple’s rankings reflect political motivations, particularly given Apple’s 2024 partnership with OpenAI to integrate ChatGPT into its Apple Intelligence suite.
You May Also Like to read:
Musk and Altman’s AI Rivalry Ignites Public Spat on X
UK data centre surge raises environmental and energy concerns
Industry Context
App Store Dynamics
Apple’s App Store, a critical gateway for app discovery, uses a mix of human curation and algorithms to determine rankings and editorial features. Grok’s rise to fifth place and second in the Productivity category, as reported by 9to5Mac, highlights its popularity, yet it trails ChatGPT, which has consistently topped charts and benefited from Apple’s editorial spotlight. Musk’s claim that Apple’s practices favor OpenAI aligns with broader scrutiny of app store policies, as seen in recent Australian rulings against Apple and Google for anti-competitive behavior ().
OpenAI’s Response
Sam Altman fired back on X, calling Musk’s claims “remarkable” and accusing him of manipulating X’s algorithm to favor his own ventures, including xAI. “Will you sign an affidavit that you’ve never directed changes to the X algorithm to harm competitors?” Altman challenged, intensifying the public spat. The exchange, viewed millions of times on X, underscores the personal and corporate stakes in the AI race, with users on the platform debating the fairness of both accusations ().
Broader Implications
Antitrust Scrutiny
Musk’s threat taps into growing regulatory focus on Big Tech’s market dominance. The European Union’s Digital Markets Act and recent U.S. court rulings against Google’s Play Store practices () signal a global push to curb anti-competitive behavior. Legal experts, like Stanford’s Mark Lemley, doubt Musk’s case would succeed without evidence of consumer harm but acknowledge it could draw regulatory attention to Apple’s curation practices. “Antitrust law is about market impact, not just favoritism,” Lemley noted.
AI Market Competition
The dispute reflects the fierce competition in AI, where app store visibility can make or break a product. xAI’s recent launch of Grok 4 and features like Grok Imagine has boosted its App Store ranking, yet OpenAI’s partnership with Apple gives ChatGPT a structural advantage. Posts on X suggest that Musk’s legal threat may be a strategic move to pressure Apple and rally public support, though some users question whether it’s a distraction from xAI’s challenges in matching ChatGPT’s market lead ().
Political and Social Context
Musk’s accusations come amid his broader critiques of tech giants and their influence, aligning with his vocal support for deregulation and free-market principles. The controversy echoes 2025 tech debates, such as HMRC’s AI-driven tax monitoring () and Denmark’s deepfake laws (), highlighting tensions between innovation, regulation, and platform power. As AI reshapes industries, Musk’s actions could set a precedent for how startups challenge entrenched tech ecosystems.
This article is based on a report by Tripp Mickle, published by The New York Times on August 12, 2025, updated at 3:17 p.m. ET. Additional context was drawn from posts on X discussing Musk’s accusations and App Store fairness.
